San Francisco loses 200,000 in workday inhabitants throughout COVID

On a typical workday earlier than the pandemic, a whole bunch of 1000’s of commuters flowed into San Francisco and Silicon Valley from across the area, swelling their daytime populations. Then COVID emptied streets and transit stations and quieted as soon as bustling retailers and eating places that catered to the weekday crowds.

A brand new report from the U.S. Census Bureau highlights simply how massive of successful distant work had on the nation’s commuter facilities.

San Francisco misplaced practically 210,000 individuals throughout a typical workday in 2021 in comparison with 2019, a Bay Space Information Group evaluation discovered, and Santa Clara County noticed a drop of practically 110,000. That drop of greater than 300,000 in what the Census calls the ‘commuter-adjusted inhabitants’ of the Bay Space’s two largest counties far outpaced — by practically 100,000 — the decline in far-larger Los Angeles.

On the flip aspect, Alameda and Contra Costa counties added tens of 1000’s to their workday populations between 2019 and 2021 as pre-pandemic commuters stayed dwelling to work.

The numbers present a startling new information level on the evolving panorama of our massive cities.

San Francisco’s transformation has been among the many most dramatic within the nation. Pre-pandemic, its inhabitants would swell to greater than 1.1 million individuals throughout work hours, about 30% bigger than the variety of residents. However the metropolis noticed an 18% drop in its estimated daytime inhabitants from July 2019 to July 2021. Santa Clara County’s fell 5%.


By comparability, New York County (Manhattan) misplaced 800,000 individuals in its commuter-adjusted inhabitants, a 24% drop from earlier than the pandemic, whereas neighboring Kings County (Brooklyn) noticed 300,000 further individuals every work day, a 14% spike.

L.A.’s drop in commuter-adjusted inhabitants — at 230,000, comparable in quantity to San Francisco — was solely a 2% lower.

Like most employees who commute to San Francisco, software program engineering supervisor Supriya Khandekar, 25, has seen the town’s downtown dramatically change since she began working there in 2019. Site visitors vanished on freeways and BART. Retailers and eating places slowed and shuttered.

“It undoubtedly grew to become very empty in the course of the pandemic itself” and it stayed that approach for some time, she stated. “It’s coming again — but it surely’s taken time.”

However it’s not simply daytime inhabitants that dropped because the pandemic. San Francisco, San Mateo and Santa Clara counties all noticed drops of their resident populations by means of 2021 as nicely.

The area’s inexpensive communities have seen the reverse. Contra Costa County has skilled the most important improve in its daytime inhabitants, including greater than 50,000 individuals, a 5% improve.

Alameda County additionally noticed a rise within the daytime inhabitants, of about 48,000, or 3%, regardless of a drop within the resident inhabitants. The rise is basically attributable to extra Alameda County residents working from dwelling and fewer commuting to close by San Francisco and Santa Clara counties.

“I feel there’s two issues taking place,” stated Abby Raisz, analysis supervisor on the Bay Space Council Financial Institute, an financial coverage assume tank. “Extra persons are working from dwelling — we’ve got the very best distant work eligibility of mainly anyplace within the nation,” she stated, and “we misplaced numerous our labor pressure too.”

Earlier than the pandemic, Marin County had the very best share of employees — 14% — of any California county who reported they labored from dwelling, in accordance with Census information that Raisz and her colleagues analyzed in a report they revealed final 12 months on distant work. In 2021, that quantity grew to 36%. However San Francisco surpassed Marin and took the highest spot with 46% of resident employees working from dwelling.

There’s proof that issues are altering. Newer information isn’t but out there, however with COVID loosening its grip within the final two years and lots of firms requiring employees return to the workplace, San Francisco’s downtown appears to be recovering. Current buzz round improvements in synthetic intelligence is spurring a flurry of investments in startups shifting into the town.

Prospects line up for his or her to-go lunch orders at Grubbies in downtown San Francisco, Calif., the place bigger crowds of commuters have been exhibiting up midweek, like on Thursday, July 6, 2023. (Karl Mondon/Bay Space Information Group) 

“There are undoubtedly extra individuals coming into downtown than in comparison with COVID, however there’s nonetheless a giant lower from earlier than the pandemic,” stated Jayden Wong, 22, a cashier at a Japanese restaurant in downtown San Francisco.

“Our goal prospects are largely workplace employees, and with extra individuals working from dwelling, there’s been much less individuals coming downtown,” Wong stated. “Individuals are steadily coming to the workplace increasingly more, however only some days per week. Monday and Friday there’s nonetheless mainly nobody, and that impacts enterprise.”

Others are extra optimistic. Preston Justice, 39, was in downtown on Thursday emceeing the Yerba Buena Gardens Pageant lunchtime jazz live performance.

“We’re bouncing again fairly nicely and seeing numbers just like earlier than the pandemic,” he stated.

Although it could imply extra crowds and probably longer commutes, Khandekar additionally hopes the return of fellow employees to downtown continues. “It’s good to see everybody coming again to the workplace, and hopefully it’ll keep this manner.”

Back to top button